- The Intrinsic Value Newsletter
- Posts
- šļø VC's Cultural Moment
šļø VC's Cultural Moment
[5 minutes to read] Plus: St. Louis's Doom Loop
By Matthew Gutierrez and Shawn OāMalley
Buy us a coffee āļø
Consumer prices rose 3.5% year-over-year (more than expected) ā a hot inflation report derailing the Fedās case for a June interest rate cut. And surveys continue to suggest that Americans remain frustrated by the cost of living.
A āsoft landingā remains elusive!
ā Matthew & Shawn
Hereās todayās rundown:
Today, we'll discuss the biggest stories in markets:
Venture capitalās cultural moment
Why St. Louis is a cautionary real estate tale
This, and more, in just 5 minutes to read.
POP QUIZ
Together With Sidebar*
Do You Want To Supercharge Your Career?
Navigating a big transition is hard to do. Itās one thing to set a lofty goal, and itās another thing to have the support system for yourself to follow through.
Sidebarās approach is focused around small peer groups, a tech-enabled platform, and an expert-led curriculum. Members say itās like having their own Personal Board of Directors.
š Nothing will get you further in your career than learning from your peers ā itās a true competitive advantage. Join over 25,000 top senior leads who have taken the first step at sidebar.com.
*Sponsored content
In The News
š Venture Capital Has A āCultural Momentā
Destinyās Website
If youāre an individual investor, you probably donāt have access to investing in hot startups. In recent years, a trendy business model in finance has been trying to change that, ādemocratizingā access to more types of companies, not just those trading on stock exchanges.
The āSPACā boom was a symptom of this, where shell companies went public, raised funds, and acquired private companies that might otherwise have difficulty listing on major stock exchanges.
Enter, DXYZ: A new fund, the Destiny 100 Tech Fund (ticker: DXYZ), is taking things one step further, āproviding everyday investors access to these private market leaders for the first time,ā according to its website.
Historically, only high-net-worth accredited investors and professionals could tap into the early growth of āunicornsā like Stripe, SpaceX, and OpenAI. By the time private tech giants go public, much of their growth is already over, leaving little meat on the bone for the masses.
Meme fund: DXYZ began trading recently, reversing that precedent with a $52 million portfolio of 23 promising private companies. Sounds great, doesnāt it?
Thereās a catch. On its first day, the fund began trading at a 1,900% premium to the estimated value of its portfolio. 1,900% ā Thatās breathtaking. Weāve seen meme stocks, now we have meme funds?
While true that the fund offers mom-and-pop investors access to startups, it offered that access at 20x their current valuation. If its investments delivered a āten-baggerā(10x return), its shares would be worth roughly half the price they traded at on Wednesday.
Why it matters:
The investor who launched the fund, Sohail Prasad, called its debut āa cultural moment thatās taken on a life of its own.ā
If youāre familiar with the mechanics of ETFs, you might wonder how a fund could garner such a premium without being arbitraged away. Well, the distinction here is that DXYZ isnāt an ETF; itās a āclosed-end fund.ā
Closed-end, not ETF: Without going too far down the rabbit hole, DXYZ couldnāt exist in ETF form since it invests in private assets, but it can as a closed-end fund, which raises money to invest in startups without the burden of investor redemptions.
As Bloombergās Matt Levine puts it, arbitrage ādoesnāt work here, because DXYZ is a closed-end fund, not an ETF. Investors cannot create or redeem shares; they canāt put money in or take money out.ā
What happens now? DXYZ is already returning to earth, down some 50% from Mondayās high. Still, its market capitalization is over an order of magnitude greater than its portfolio value (aka net asset value.)
This means it has a great opportunity to sell more shares, raise capital at a massive premium, and invest more in startups.
As Levine says, if done at scale, that would actually ācollapse the premiumā for its shares. While other venture capital funds have struggled to raise money, DXYZ almost has more demand for its shares than it knows what to do with.
More Headlines
š FCC rolls out mandatory ānutrition labelsā for internet providersā plans
š The NCAA womenās basketball final outrated the menās for the first time ever
š Rich Americans are getting second passports, citing risk of instability
š Nvidiaās stock enters correction territory, down 10%
āļø FAA investigating Boeing over another whistleblower claim
š®š³ How Indiaās market cap could āeasilyā jump ten-fold in two decades
š± The Real Estate Nightmare in St. Louis: āDoom Loopā
Made Using DALL-E
Chalk up St. Louis as the latest cautionary real estate tale, symbolic of another great American city now a shadow of its former self.
The Railway Exchange Building, once the heart of downtown St. Louis, is abandoned and deteriorating. Many of its windows are boarded up due to a fire suspected to be caused by copper thieves.
The building's decline reflects a broader trend affecting American downtowns, exacerbated by the pandemic's impact on office attendance.
St. Louis has experienced a sharp decline in its central business district, with the steepest drop in foot traffic among 66 major North American cities. This decline has led to closed shops, restaurants, and empty office buildings, creating a desolate atmosphere.
Chicken and egg: The situation results from decades of decay, including population loss, competition from suburban offices, and failed urban planning. The closure of Macy's department store in the Railway Exchange Building in 2013 triggered a cascade of vacancies and closures in surrounding businesses.
The AT&T Tower downtown sold for $205 million in 2006. In 2022, it went for just $4 million.
āItās a classic chicken and egg kind of deal,ā said a professor of economics at Washington University. āPeople donāt go there because thereās nothing to do. Thereās nothing to do because people donāt go there.ā
Revival efforts: Efforts to revive the area include adding landscaping, bike lanes, and traffic barriers and offering subsidies to retailers and developers. However, revitalization remains challenging due to low rents, high construction costs, and the reluctance of private developers to invest in the struggling district.
Silver linings: There are signs of hope. Downtown West, a neighboring area, has seen revitalization through investments in loft apartments, a new soccer stadium, and other attractions, though thereās plenty of work to be done.
Why it matters:
St. Louis's downtown district is a cautionary tale for other American cities facing similar challenges.
Heartland struggles: American downtowns havenāt all had it easy, especially cities away from the coasts. While cities in Florida and Texas are thriving, those in the heartland havenāt had it too good. Consider: Six of the 10 U.S. office districts with the steepest drop in foot traffic between 2019 and mid-2023 are in the Midwest.
As The Wall Street Journal reports: āNow, St. Louis stands as a warning to others: This is the future for Americaās downtowns if they canāt reinvent themselves and halt the downward spiral.ā
Together With Money.com*
Diversify Your Portfolio & Safeguard Your Retirement
Safeguarding your retirement with a Gold IRA can help you shield your wealth from market shifts, economic uncertainty, and inflation.
And with goldās value projected to increase in 2024, now is a good time to invest. Planning for retirement involves more than saving, so fortify your portfolio with gold today and plan for a better tomorrow.
See our list of Best Gold IRA Companies to start planning a better retirement.
*Sponsored content
Quick Poll
Do you think St. Louis, and similar midwest cities struggling with hollowed-out downtowns, can turn things around? |
Yesterday, we asked: Are you investing more in commodities this year?
ā Said one reader, āIām already overweight in oil and commodity. If I were to load up, it should have been in 2023.ā Wrote another, āThere are 3 rules in speculating in commodities. 1) Never go long. 2) Never go short. 3) Make sure you didnāt go short.ā
ā On team Yes, āGold via ETF in my permanent portfolio.ā
TRIVIA ANSWER
See you next time!
That's it for today on We Study Markets!
If youāre a sophisticated investor looking for more professional insights, check out We Study Markets Pro.
Enjoy reading this newsletter? Forward it to a friend.
Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up here.
Use the promo code STOCKS15 at checkout for 15% off our popular course āHow To Get Started With Stocks.ā
Advertise with us.
Follow us on Twitter.
Keep an eye on your inbox for our newsletters on weekdays around 6pm EST and on weekends. If you have any feedback for us, simply respond to this email.
You can also leave your comments/suggestions/feedback anonymously here.
What did you think of today's newsletter? |
All the best,
P.S. The Investor's Podcast Network is excited to launch a subreddit devoted to our fans in discussing financial markets, stock picks, questions for our hosts, and much more!
Join our subreddit r/TheInvestorsPodcast today!
Ā© The Investor's Podcast Network content is for educational purposes only. The calculators, videos, recommendations, and general investment ideas are not to be actioned with real money. Contact a professional and certified financial advisor before making any financial decisions. No one at The Investor's Podcast Network are professional money managers or financial advisors. The Investorās Podcast Network and parent companies that own The Investorās Podcast Network are not responsible for financial decisions made from using the materials provided in this email or on the website.